Roof Repair vs Roof Replacement

Nutley Roof Repairs

Written by Danielle Nigro

December 13, 2016

Get a Free Estimate!

Provide us with a little information and we will provide you with a FREE Estimate

10 + 13 =

Are you looking into Nutley roof repair for you home? Freezing ice and snow, strong winds, pounding rain and hot sun all take a beating on your roof.  The roof is a home’s first line of defense and is therefore very important to maintain.  If you are having noticeable problems with your roof such as leaks, missing shingles or rot, it’s time to take immediate roof repair action to prevent further damage to your home. As you are probably aware, there are different options when it comes to Nutley roof repair: reroofing and roof replacement.  reroofing has become well known for being a cheaper alternative to roof replacement.  reroofing has the potential to save you money, however, it is not ideal for every situation.  As a homeowner, it is important that you understand the difference between reroofing and roof replacement so that you can make informed decisions when you hire a roofing contractor to repair your roof!

Nutley Roof Repair Service

Nutley Roof Repair | Reroofing Overview

Reroofing is a method of repairing an old or worn out roof.  It involves layering new shingles on top of the old worn out shingles.  This reinforces the strength of the roof and can prevent further damage from occurring.  There is no need to remove the old shingles, so the process is much faster then roof replacement which requires tear off.  Because it takes less time, reroofing is usually significantly lower in cost than a complete replacement.  Although reroofing is an effective solution to you roof repair needs, it can only be done one time.  This means that if you already have a double layer of shingles on your roof, this method of Nutley roof repair is not an option for you.

Roof Repairs in Nutley | Roof Replacement Overview

Unlike reroofing, a complete roof replacement requires removing all the old shingles down to the wooden deck below.  After the shingles have been completely torn off, new felt paper is applied to the wooden deck and fresh shingles are nailed to the roof.  Also unlike reroofing, a replacement can be done regardless of how many layers of shingles are currently on your roof. However, the extra work and time involved in the roof replacement procedure typically make it a more expensive project compared to reroofing.

When Reroofing Can Be a Good Nutley Roof Repair Method

If your roof is generally in good condition, but is beginning to show significant wear and tear, then reroofing is a good way to go.  Minor leaks or a few missing shingles are not a cause to replace the entire roof, but still require your attention. Reroofing is a great way to restore health and longevity to your roof without completely replacing it.  As long as there isn’t any serious water damage, a significant amount of missing shingles, or mold overgrowth, reroofing is a great option that will prolong your roof’s lifespan and save you money. Reroofing is usually a good option for preparing a roof for Fall and Winter.

Roof Repair in Nutley NJ | When Not to Reroof

Although it has it’s place in roof repair, sometimes reroofing is not the best route to take. Reroofing doesn’t involve tearing out the old shingles, so there is absolutely no way to know what condition the wooden deck underneath is in.  Problems can usually be spotted by looking at the condition of the shingles, however, there are some instances where the wood under the shingles has begun to rot. In this situation, reroofing further conceals a serous problemwithout providing a solution to the damage.  This will only cause further damage to your roof and home costing you much more than you would have paid for a complete roof replacement.

Reroofing is also not a good idea if only certain areas of your roof need to be done. Not reroofing the entire roof at once will result in sections of roofing that do not line up properly with one another.  The uneveness of the roof is very noticeable and can cause damage to occur to your roof that could have been prevented.

It is also very important to keep in mind that Reroofing can be done only if there is a single layer of shingles on the roof. Although it is not uncommon to come across a roofer who is willing to reroof over multiple layers of shingles, the risk outweighs the potential benefit.  When dealing with multiple layers of shingles, the nails used may not be able to penetrate through the layers to hold the newest shingles in place. Additionally, more than one layer of shingles makes it very difficult to detect if there is any damage to the wooden deck underneath.  This increases the possibility that a serious problem could go unnoticed.  For tips on identifing serious problems, checkout “signs it’s time to replace your roof

Nutley Roofing Repair | When to Replace

Unlike reroofing, there is never a wrong time for a roof replacement.  If there are multiple shingles already on a roof, a replacement should always be done.  If there is mold, rot or other damage to the wood under the shingles, a replacement should always be done. Additionally if both the roof the shingles are in bad condition, a replacement is the best option.  A replacement allows all problems (both known and unknown) to be solved simultaneously instead of simply covered up by another layer of shingles.

After everything is said and done, there is only a small window of opportunity where reroofing is a worthwhile option.  If your roof doesn’t meet that criteria, a replacement will save you more time, money and frustration that reroofing in the long run.

Deegan Roofing | Best Nutley Roof Repair Contractor

Deegan Roofing, has been specializing in Nutley roof repair services for over 25 years.  Deegan Roofing provides roof repair, roof replacement and a variety of other Nutley roofing services.  As a family owned and operated business, we are among the largest and most trusted roofers in the great state of New Jersey. Customer satisfaction is our number one priority and we make sure to only use the highest quality materials to provide outstanding services.  With countless projects under our belt, we are always ready to work with both new and existing customers. We specialize in Nutley roof repair, but we also provide Fanwood roof repair, Clark roof repair, Westfield roof repair, and we serve the towns of Edison, Warren, Cranford, Clifton, Wayne, Paramus and MANY more. Contact us today for more information!

NJ Roofing Contractor

NJ Roofing

NJ Roofing Contractor

NJ Roofing Company

Related NJ Roofing Posts:

Roof Repair vs Roof Replacement

Roof Installation

NJ Roof Repairs

Why Roof Repair

Union County Roofers

Passaic County Roofers

Bergen County Roofer

North Jersey Roofers

You May Also Like…

Best Hunterdon County Roofer

If you have a roofing project that needs to be done, it's safe to assume that you'd want to look for the best...

Hunterdon County Roofing Services

Do you know whether or not you're in need of Hunterdon County roofing services? If you notice damage to your shingles,...

Get a Free Estimate!

Provide us with a little information and we will provide you with a FREE Estimate

13 + 3 =

Brien Deegan is the company owner and founder. “I attribute much of our longevity and success to a number of factors. We are a family owned and operated company, with my sons and Michael Deegan, my nephew, right at my side. I have a great, hand-picked staff of people who have been with us a long time. Above all that, our goal has always been to put honesty and the needs of our customers ahead of profit.”

After 30 years in the roofing business, Deegan Roofing holds a state license in good standing and a complaint-free record, an A+ Better Bureau Business rating, Deegan still personally writes up many estimates in order to have personal contact with his customers.

Deegan Roofing is highly committed to giving back helping the community. They work with charitable groups and veterans organizations on a regular basis. Currently in partnership with GAF, they are helping military veterans and retirees in the Roofs for Troops program



Our roofing services include roof repair, roof installation, roof inspections and more. We only offer high quality materials. Our experienced team takes on projects of any size, and will work with you to ensure you end up with the roof you want.


Our gutter services include seamless gutter installation, gutter repair and more. We only offer high quality gutter products. Whether you need gutters for a new home, or you need your gutters replaced, we are ready to get started!


Our siding services include siding installation, siding repair and more. We only offer high quality GAF and James Hardie siding products. Our experienced team takes on projects of any size, and will work with you to ensure you end up with the perfect siding !


Our contractors at Deegan Roofing have been offering quality service and products since 1989. As a family owned business, we understand that you want and need the best structure for you and your home.

Check Out Our Contracting Company

Renovations | Remodeling | Mold | Masonry | Hardscapes

nj seo company